Something is at war with us, ‘us’ being regular citizens who want things to work and to be left alone. We’re slow to react because we think in terms of nations. Our enemies are mafias that wear our governments like a cloak to defeat our eyes, and fly our flags to disarm our minds — Bret Weinstein

link


One thought on “Something is at war with us, ‘us’ being regular citizens who want things to work and to be left alone. We’re slow to react because we think in terms of nations. Our enemies are mafias that wear our governments like a cloak to defeat our eyes, and fly our flags to disarm our minds — Bret Weinstein

  1. The article raises the question of whether Bret Weinstein’s influence should make us more careful about examining the limits of his arguments.

    A more precise criticism concerns his treatment of the origin of life. Weinstein recognizes that heredity is the threshold that turns ordinary physical selection into biological evolution. Yet he often invokes Darwinian evolution as the ultimate explanation for biological complexity and intelligence without explaining how the first hereditary, self-reproducing system arose.

    That distinction matters. Evolution can explain how living systems change once replication, heredity, variation, and selection already exist. It does not, by itself, explain how nonliving chemistry first became capable of those processes.

    For a prominent evolutionary thinker who speaks confidently about creation, intelligence, and ultimate causation, this is not a minor missing detail. It is the central unresolved problem. His influence makes the omission more consequential because many listeners may come away believing that evolution and the origin of evolution are the same question.

    I explore this further here:

    Life Against Entropy: Cloning, the Origin of Life, and Gurdjieff’s Creation Story
    https://tonylutz.com/intelligence/something-else-entirely/612-612

Leave a comment